Stop Solving the Wrong Problems (The 5 Whys Will Change Everything)
Alright, let me tell you about the most powerful question in business, and it’s also the simplest one you’ll ever ask. Just three letters. One word. Infinite power when you’re brave enough to keep asking it.
Why?
That’s it! That’s the whole game right there! Except here’s the thing that separates the people who actually solve problems from the ones who just put band-aids on symptoms – you gotta ask it five times! Not once. Not twice when you’re feeling thorough. Five times! Each one digging deeper, each one getting closer to the truth, each one peeling back another layer of the onion until you’re standing face to face with the real issue that’s been hiding underneath all the surface-level noise!
And I’m fired up about this because I’m watching companies waste millions of dollars, countless hours, and immeasurable energy solving problems that aren’t even the actual problems! They’re treating symptoms while the disease runs wild underneath, wondering why nothing ever really gets better no matter how hard they work!
Alex Karp at Palantir gets this at a level that most people never will!
The man built one of the most consequential software companies in the world by refusing to accept surface-level answers. By pushing past the comfortable explanations. By being relentless about getting to root causes instead of settling for whatever story makes everyone feel better! And you know what that philosophy created? Products that actually solve the problems they’re meant to solve instead of just creating new ones!
But let me show you what I mean because this isn’t theoretical – this is practical as it gets!
Most people stop at the first “why” and think they’ve done something profound!
“Why did our product launch fail?”
“Because customers didn’t adopt it.”
And then what happens? The whole team rallies around driving adoption! They build new marketing campaigns, they offer discounts, they create training materials, they push harder on sales. And maybe adoption ticks up a little bit, but the fundamental problem hasn’t been touched because they never asked the second why!
“Why didn’t customers adopt it?”
“Because it didn’t fit their workflow.”
Okay, now we’re getting somewhere! But we’re still not there yet! Keep going!
“Why didn’t it fit their workflow?”
“Because we built it based on what we thought they needed instead of understanding how they actually work.”
There it is! We’re starting to see the real issue! But we’re not done!
“Why did we build based on assumptions instead of understanding?”
“Because our product development process doesn’t include enough customer interaction during the design phase.”
Now we’re cooking! One more!
“Why doesn’t our process include customer interaction?”
“Because we prioritize speed to market over validation, and we’ve structured our teams in ways that create distance between builders and users.”
BOOM! There’s your root cause!
The surface problem was “customers didn’t adopt our product.” The real problem was an organizational structure and cultural priority that creates distance between the people building things and the people using them! You can throw all the marketing money in the world at that first problem and you’ll never fix it! But address that fifth why and suddenly everything changes!
This is what separates good product management from great product management!
The mediocre product managers are out there asking what features to build next. The good ones are asking why customers want those features. But the great ones? The ones building products that actually matter? They’re asking why five times and discovering things that completely reframe how they think about the problem!
And I’m telling you, this isn’t just about products – this applies to every problem worth solving!
“Why are we losing our best people?”
“Why are they looking for other opportunities?”
“Why don’t they feel challenged here?”
“Why have we stopped investing in complex, meaningful work?”
“Why have we optimized for efficiency over innovation?”
Suddenly you’re not talking about retention bonuses, you’re talking about fundamental business strategy! You’re not treating symptoms, you’re addressing causes! You’re not putting band-aids on, you’re actually healing!
But here’s where most organizations fall apart – they’re terrified of where those five whys might lead!
Because when you’re honest about it, when you really dig deep, you’re gonna uncover some uncomfortable truths! You’re gonna find that the problem isn’t some external force or market condition or bad luck – it’s choices you made, systems you built, priorities you set! And that’s hard to face! That requires humility! That requires being willing to acknowledge that you might have been wrong about some fundamental assumptions!
This is why I love that Karp lives this philosophy! He’s not afraid of uncomfortable answers! He’s not interested in explanations that let everyone off the hook! He wants the truth because the truth is the only thing that lets you build solutions that actually work!
The 5 Whys is ultimately about intellectual honesty!
It’s about refusing to let yourself off easy. Refusing to accept the first explanation that sounds plausible. Refusing to stop digging when you hit something that makes you uncomfortable. It’s about caring more about solving the actual problem than about protecting egos or maintaining comfortable narratives!
And in product development, this is absolutely critical! Because every product is a hypothesis about what problem exists and how to solve it! And if your hypothesis is based on surface-level understanding, you’re building the wrong thing! You might build it beautifully, you might execute flawlessly, but you’ll have executed perfectly on solving a problem that isn’t the real problem!
I’ve seen this play out so many times it makes my head spin!
Teams spending months building features nobody asked for because they never asked why anyone would want them in the first place. Companies pivoting their entire strategy based on feedback that addressed symptoms rather than causes. Leaders making big bets on solutions to problems they never fully understood because they stopped asking why after the first or second iteration!
And here’s what kills me – the 5 Whys isn’t complicated! It’s not some advanced framework that requires specialized training! It’s literally just asking “why” five times and being honest about the answers! But it requires something that’s actually harder than any technical skill – it requires ego suspension and genuine curiosity!
You gotta be willing to be wrong. Willing to discover that your initial understanding was incomplete. Willing to follow the thread wherever it leads even if it leads to conclusions that are inconvenient or challenging or require major changes to how you operate!
This is where Palantir’s approach gets really interesting!
They’re building software that helps organizations make sense of complex data and make better decisions. And you know what the foundation of that is? Understanding the real problems those organizations are trying to solve! Not the surface-level “we need better analytics” but the deep, structural challenges that drive the need for better analytics in the first place!
When Palantir works with a client, they’re not just delivering software – they’re excavating understanding! They’re asking why until they get to bedrock! And that’s why their solutions actually work instead of just creating new problems or shifting the burden somewhere else!
So how do you actually implement this in product development?
First, you gotta create a culture where asking why isn’t seen as being difficult or obstructive. It’s seen as being thorough and responsible! Where pushing past comfortable answers is valued rather than discouraged! Where the goal is truth rather than consensus!
Second, you gotta train yourself and your teams to recognize when you’re stopping too early. When the answer feels a little too clean, a little too convenient, a little too focused on external factors rather than internal choices – that’s your signal to keep digging!
Third, you gotta be willing to act on what you discover! Because the worst thing you can do is ask five whys, uncover the real problem, and then go back to treating symptoms because addressing the root cause is too hard or too disruptive! That’s worse than not asking at all because now you know you’re avoiding the real issue!
And here’s the beautiful part about making this a habit – it compounds!
The more you practice digging deeper, the better you get at recognizing surface-level thinking in real-time. The more comfortable you become with uncomfortable truths. The more skilled you become at designing solutions that address root causes rather than symptoms. You start building products that solve problems people didn’t even realize they had because you understood their situation better than they did!
This is how you create competitive advantages that are actually defensible! Because anyone can copy your features, but they can’t copy the depth of understanding that led to those features! They can’t replicate the customer insight that came from asking why five times when they’re still stuck on answer number one!
The 5 Whys is also the antidote to building for the sake of building!
You know what happens in a lot of product organizations? People get excited about technology or capabilities or what’s possible, and they start building without ever really understanding why it matters! They create solutions in search of problems! And then they wonder why adoption is low or why customers don’t see the value!
But when you’re disciplined about the 5 Whys, you can’t build in a vacuum! You have to understand the problem at a level that makes it impossible to create solutions that miss the mark! You’ve done the work to ensure that what you’re building actually addresses what needs addressing!
This is also how you avoid getting seduced by false metrics!
“Why are our engagement numbers down?”
“Because users aren’t logging in as frequently.”
Stop there and you’ll optimize for login frequency! You’ll build features that drive more logins! And you might succeed at that metric while completely missing that the reason people aren’t logging in is because your product isn’t solving their problem anymore!
Keep asking why and you’ll discover the real issue – maybe the market shifted, maybe competitors solved the problem better, maybe the problem itself evolved and your solution didn’t! And now you’re equipped to build something that actually matters instead of just gaming a metric!
What I love about this approach is how democratizing it is!
You don’t need to be a genius to ask why five times. You don’t need an MBA or special training or years of experience. You just need curiosity and courage! The willingness to dig deeper and the bravery to face what you find!
This levels the playing field in the best possible way! A junior product manager who’s disciplined about the 5 Whys can outperform a senior one who stops at surface-level understanding! A small team that really understands their customers’ root problems can outcompete a huge organization that’s solving the wrong problems at scale!
And in problem-solving more broadly, this is transformational!
Your team missing deadlines? Ask why five times and you might discover it’s not about time management – it’s about unclear priorities, conflicting objectives, or technical debt that’s slowing everything down.
Your customers churning? Ask why five times and you might discover it’s not about pricing or features – it’s about misaligned expectations set during the sales process.
Your innovation stalling? Ask why five times and you might discover it’s not about lack of ideas – it’s about risk aversion built into your approval processes and incentive structures!
The pattern is always the same – surface symptoms point to deeper causes!
And the only way to get from one to the other is by being relentless about understanding why. Not accepting the first explanation. Not stopping when things get uncomfortable. Not settling for answers that protect existing assumptions or avoid difficult changes!
This is what separates organizations that evolve and adapt from ones that keep making the same mistakes in different forms! The ones that ask why five times learn and improve. The ones that stop after one or two keep bumping into the same problems wearing different disguises!
So here’s my challenge to everyone reading this:
Pick a problem you’re dealing with right now. Could be in product development, could be organizational, could be personal. Whatever it is, commit to asking why five times. Really doing it, not just going through the motions. Being honest about each answer. Following the thread wherever it leads!
I guarantee you’ll discover something you didn’t know. Something that reframes how you think about the problem. Something that opens up solution paths you hadn’t considered because you were focused on the surface issue instead of the root cause!
And if you’re leading a team, make this a practice! When someone brings you a problem, don’t accept their first explanation of what’s causing it. Ask why. When they answer, ask why again. Keep going until you hit something that feels fundamental, that couldn’t be explained by asking another why!
This is how Karp built Palantir into what it is! This is how the best product teams in the world create solutions that actually matter! This is how you stop wasting time and resources on things that don’t address real problems!
It’s simple but it’s not easy! It requires discipline, honesty, and courage! It means being willing to discover that your initial understanding was wrong. That the problem you thought you were solving isn’t the problem at all. That the real issue is deeper, more fundamental, more challenging than you wanted to believe!
But that’s also what makes it powerful! Because once you see the real problem, once you understand it at a root level, you can build solutions that actually work! Solutions that don’t just shift symptoms around but actually resolve the underlying issues! Solutions that create lasting value instead of temporary fixes!
The 5 Whys isn’t just a technique – it’s a philosophy!
It’s a commitment to depth over surface-level understanding. To truth over comfortable narratives. To solving real problems over treating symptoms. To building things that matter over building things that look good in presentations!
And in a world where everyone’s moving fast, where there’s pressure to ship quickly and iterate later, where surface-level analysis is the norm – this depth of understanding is a competitive advantage that’s almost impossible to replicate!
So ask why! And then ask it again! And again! Until you hit bedrock! Until you understand not just what’s happening but why it’s happening at the most fundamental level!
That’s how you build products that change industries! That’s how you solve problems that seemed unsolvable! That’s how you create value that’s real and lasting instead of fleeting and superficial!
And that’s what separates the people who are really building something from the ones who are just going through the motions! The willingness to dig deeper, to ask harder questions, to face uncomfortable truths, and to act on what they discover!
Now get out there and start asking why! Five times! Every time! Watch how it transforms everything!
SPINMANTV.ME 
Leave a comment